I was standing there, phone screen glowing, hovering over the confirmation button for a ridiculous, beautiful thing. It was $3,008, a small abstract work that used colors I hadn’t known existed until I saw them-a deep, bruised indigo next to a searing, almost radioactive coral. Pure, immediate joy.
And then, the whisper. The demand for financial validation instantly sucked the oxygen out of the aesthetic experience. We treat beauty like futures trading.
I closed the tab. I missed the bus earlier this week by ten seconds, and the sheer inefficiency of that moment-the wasted sprint, the sudden stop-felt exactly like this internal feeling: paralyzed by the societal demand for quantifiable efficiency in a moment that demands subjective presence. We are so relentlessly trained to financialize everything-our homes, our health, our time-that we’ve systematically forgotten how to simply *be* pleased, purely, without calculating the return.
The Illusion of the Blue-Chip Hedge
We’ve all seen the headlines. Some massive, museum-grade piece sells for $88 million, and suddenly, every clean gallery floor transforms, in the average buyer’s mind, into Sotheby’s. This narrative, while statistically true for the top 0.008% of the art market, is utterly corrosive to the 99% of us looking at a piece that costs $8,008 or $18,008.
The brutal, essential truth? If you are buying art from an emerging or mid-career artist-which you absolutely should be, because that is where the soul of the culture truly lives-you are likely buying something that will never return its original value financially. And that should not just be acceptable; it should be celebrated.
From “Does it move me?” to “Does it conform to market trends?”
The second you frame a piece of art not as something to live with, but as something to flip, you fundamentally change the criteria for selection. You stop asking the necessary, human questions: “Does this specific texture hold my gaze?” Instead, you start asking, “Does the signature signal collectability?”
The True Value Proposition
This is where the contrarian value lies: It solves the paralysis of choice induced by financial insecurity. If you want a proven financial investment, buy an index fund. If you want a piece of history that guarantees appreciation, you need capital in the neighborhood of $238,888,888.
Most of us are just trying to find a piece that doesn’t clash violently with the sofa and makes the process of drinking morning coffee slightly more bearable. Supporting independent spaces and the individual livelihoods of creators is a beautiful, necessary act.
“
For genuine, original work, especially in areas like Port Melbourne, spaces like Port Art cut through that relentless financial noise. They prioritize the artist and the personal connection, not the projected asset class.
The Companion in Struggle
I once met a man named Theo N., who obsessed over mechanical accuracy in watch movements. But his apartment was full of things that made no financial sense: a vast, terrible-but-glorious canvas he bought 18 years prior for $878.
The painting was a companion in struggle. It sat there, an ugly totem of survival, witnessing the chaos Theo fought to organize every day.
When I asked if it appreciated, Theo laughed. “It appreciated in value. It has witnessed 8,008 decisions I have made in this room… it reminds me that concentrated effort doesn’t always lead to a clean movement; sometimes it just leads to a big, beautiful mess that you have to learn to live with.”
Monetary Appreciation (Likely)
Serenity & Memory Dividend
Measuring Serenity, Not Liquidity
We must stop using the accountant’s ledger to measure purely personal joy. When you buy a good mattress, you calculate the 2,928 nights of improved, restorative sleep it will give you. When you take a perfect vacation, you calculate the mental health dividend it pays for the next 8 months. Yet, for visual culture, we insist on treating it like a stock certificate.
My own mistake years ago was prioritizing speculative profit over present joy. I convinced myself that the anxiety I felt about the purchase was sophisticated ‘market tension.’ It wasn’t. I allowed the promise of future money to destroy the possibility of present happiness.
If the art is a hedge against the overwhelming chaos of life, its return is measured in serenity. If it is a marker of personal growth, its return is measured in memory and reflection. You pay for the right to hold that conversation with that object for the rest of your life.
The question we should be asking when facing that $3,008 confirmation screen isn’t, “Will this appreciate, and how much?” It’s this: “If this piece was worth absolutely nothing but the paint on the canvas 18 years from now, would I still be deeply, fundamentally glad I spent the money?”
If the answer is yes, click buy. You’ve already won. If the answer is no, you are not buying art; you are placing a low-confidence bet on a highly volatile market.